We find ourselves in the teenage years of the dominant social media platforms – Facebook is 20 years old; Instagram is 14; and 18-year-old Twitter has angrily changed its name to X. As with any teenager, volatility is the norm. Recent years brought us the mountainous rise of TikTok, the faltering of Twitter, the birth of Threads, the rise and fall of the metaverse, Bill C-18, Apple’s app tracking transparency, and generative AI for all. There’s been a tremendous amount of change.
Constant change and disruption are woven into the fabric of the digital landscape. So how do communicators and marketers navigate these rapid transformations of technology, norms, and tastes? There are really only two choices – radical change every quarter or create a long-term, stable social strategy. The former is going to consistently get you into trouble, the latter will set you up for success for years to come.
Just because platforms are volatile doesn’t mean brands have to be. Amidst the chaos, the smart move is to create integrated strategies that bring together social, creative, media, and web teams to curate moments and create ownable content focused on measurable goals.
If users don’t win, everyone loses
We are in the midst of a fierce battle for attention. Consumer ability to jump toward shiny new platforms is forever shifting how social media properties operate. As communicators, we should be rooting for more success, not failure. A healthy, competitive social media ecosystem is better for all of us as it incentivizes communicators to create compelling messaging.
Meta’s platforms, along with TikTok’s, increasingly suffer from a proliferation of out-of-touch and socially disconnected ads. A surge in poorly crafted – and often auto-generated messaging results in user disengagement; they post less frequently, see less of what they want, and before you know it, you’re in a platform death spiral. This cycle creates a worse environment for users, contributing to declining diversity, doom-scrolling and deteriorating mental health – which is a lousy environment for organizations to communicate in with users.
No one should add to this deterioration. Marketers and communicators must be thoughtful about what we bring to the party. Audiences want to be seen and acknowledged, and they crave relevant content. Brands who lead with authenticity and demonstrate they understand the diversity of their customers’ values will continue to flourish.
Paid and organic: BFFs
Organic reach is dead. But that doesn’t mean organic efforts should be abandoned. It just means that paid campaigns and organic publishing shouldn’t operate in silos, and certainly not with distinct teams behind them. Organic and paid should be part of the same strategy conversation – with creative and media at the table. Paid and organic can complement each other strongly. Organic audiences are engaged supporters, driving content views, comments and organic website sessions. Organic content nurtures and informs those who know your brand or your perspective. These audiences are your most loyal, and insights from their actions and interests will inform your paid audience targeting, and your next round of creative content planning. On the flip side, within your best-performing social media content – that’s tested across millions of targeted impressions and dozens of AI-powered creative treatments – lies the spark for your next most engaging organic content.
Bigger! Better! Fewer!
Face it, very few are waiting for your organization’s next social media post. You should be communicating when you have something relevant to say. It’s more effective to focus your integrated social media efforts within your brand’s own schedule. Find your most meaningful and most impactful moments. Pick your times to speak, and break through with meaning, authenticity, and the weight of a focused ad spend to drive higher exposure for the moments that matter (to you and your audiences). Less is more!
Bigger moments are more likely to align with strategic outcomes. And social media outcomes should be a means to an end, aligning with actual business objectives. Your organization is not powered by impressions and likes. Calibrate your conversions and turn on an ecosystem that is fine-tuned to nurture first-party customer data – data from which you can grow more meaningful relationships. Engaged audiences are more likely to connect through to your websites, your ecommerce shop, your CRM initiatives and your physical assets.
Embrace platform formats
The smartphone is the TV of today. And vertical video is its 22-minute sitcom. XDR screens and 5G networks have made social media feeds the perfect place for vertical video entertainment. Steve Jobs dreamed of an entertainment and communications device for the park bench, the bus and the bathroom. And now we have it, full-screen and lightning fast. Today, content carrying your message needs to resonate with your mobile viewer within just 2 seconds. This is why your creative and social media teams should integrate from the start, so that possibilities are never missed. Your content planning and production stream can be designed to incorporate native platform truths, from the start. The format is vertical, short, and quickly engaging – with branding and key message right up front.
Because social media is so volatile, we as marketers need to be extra-focused on stability. When users, platforms and policies ebb and flow, integration and cohesion are our secret weapons. Increase the proximity between social, creative, media and web teams. Lead with authenticity. Embrace and test new platform formats. These are the efforts that enhance immediate success during these platform teen years and prepare us for weathering the expected volatility ahead.
Share
About the author
Matthew Stradiotto / Senior Vice President, Social Media
Matthew is a digital leader, brand strategist, and North American influencer engagement pioneer, with over 22 years of agency experience. He was recently Vice President & General Manager, Digital at Argyle, and a co-founder of Matchstick, one of Canada’s leading boutique agencies specializing in social media marketing and digital brand engagement.
Breaking down Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) stigma through engagement and action
Leveraging research and real-time solutions, the Locked Out campaign facilitated education and understanding of an invisible disease to break down barriers related to stigma and washroom accessibility for those who live with Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis.
Crohn’s & Colitis Canada
Crohn’s and Colitis Canada is a leading national charity dedicated to finding cures and improving the lives of those with IBD.
Expertise
Health
Reputation Management
Services
Creative strategy
Earned media, influencer relations and partnerships
Strategic Counsel
Challenge
The Locked Out campaign faced several challenges to raise awareness for IBD and public washroom accessibility. The activation — a real portable toilet placed in a public space — often led to preconceived assumptions, mirroring the stigma those with IBD face when seeking washrooms. This reinforced the need for targeted engagement to shift perceptions.
Stigma remains a barrier, as understanding of IBD, its symptoms and patient experiences are often overlooked. Positioning the stunt within Crohn’s and Colitis Awareness Month and sharing educational information was essential to breaking down misconceptions. The campaign relied on knowledgeable event staff to effectively communicate the message, which was supported by QR codes, signage, and live app demonstrations to ensure accessibility and education.
Engaging passers-by required adaptable strategies to capture attention and encourage participation. Crohn’s and Colitis Canada’s network of advocates played a key role in staffing the event, providing credible voices to reinforce the campaign’s message. Maximizing visibility required a strategic mix of organic and paid social content, ensuring reach beyond the physical activation. Targeted media outreach focused on Toronto to optimize resources and drive coverage, reinforcing the campaign’s urgency and impact.
Insight
To effectively engage key stakeholders and promote the GoHere® app during Crohn’s and Colitis Awareness Month, we analyzed and applied existing research on the needs and challenges of those who live with IBD. It was important to understand disease prevalence and patient experiences to ensure our program resonated with audiences. We examined insights into public washroom access barriers, stigma, and the need for real-time solutions, ensuring our messaging addressed the most pressing concerns. We also leveraged Vividata research to deepen our understanding of audience behaviors and media consumption patterns. These insights guided our strategic approach, enabling us to craft compelling content, target key demographics, and maximize engagement across multiple channels.
IBD Patients
IBD diagnosis rates in Canada are increasing – and so are the needs for support. There is no cure for IBD. Approximately 322,000 Canadians live with IBD, with new diagnoses every 48 minutes. Patients experience lifestyle impacts, including chronic abdominal pain, frequent bathroom visits, and fatigue.1 Addressing IBD requires a thoughtful, sensitive, and real approach to the stigma that patients experience. Our strategy balanced empathy with practical solutions to drive engagement and app downloads.
Additional research findings: IBD often develops in young adults, typically between 16 and 35 years old, but can occur at any age. A second peak may occur in individuals over 60. Both men and women are equally affected.1 Patients experience significant lifestyle and psychosocial impacts such as mental health, diet and nutrition, and work and social life; Psychiatric disorders frequently occur among those with IBD: An estimated 21% have clinical anxiety; and an estimated 15% have clinical depression.2
News and social media consumption habits: Mobile (hours per week)3: Gen Z: 16.8; Millennial: 10.1; Gen X: 12.8; Social applications (hours per week)3: Gen Z: 15.8; Millennial: 15.1; Gen X: 8.2; TV (hours per week)3: Gen Z: 14.4; Millennial: 17.5; Gen X: 16.5; Online (hours per week)3: Gen Z: 28.7; Millennial: 25.6; Gen X: 24.7.
IBD Caregivers
Those who care for individuals who live with IBD, usually family members, close friends or partners of those diagnosed. Research revealed that 56 per cent of caregivers feel exhausted from caregiving duties, and 44% report anxiety.4 Women are more likely to take on the caregiver role for children with IBD.5 IBD caregivers in Canada are essential to the well-being of individuals living with the condition. We needed to show support for the care they provide and make them aware of the GoHere® app to increase downloads and usage.
Policymakers: Those who shape public policy and address issues through legislation and decision-making. For non-profit organizations, this audience can influence resources, support advocacy efforts and shape the broader environment in which Crohn’s and Colitis Canada operates. Engagement with policymakers was essential to raise awareness and garner support for washroom accessibility initiatives in a sensitive way to make it easy for this audience to share our messages. We needed a demonstration of local political support to increase awareness and action.
News Media and Social Media: We targeted top-tier health reporters, online news outlets, and Crohn’s and Colitis Canada’s active social platforms (FB & IG) to reach key audiences. Insights showed that Gen Z, Millennials, and Gen X spend significant time on mobile and social media, making a shareable, timely event essential. Personal patient stories highlighted the GoHere® app’s impact, driving awareness and downloads. Securing a national health reporter with a personal connection to IBD further amplified engagement within the IBD community.
Environmental Scan: To understand the IBD landscape, we reviewed media coverage and patient testimonials. Results showed IBD awareness remains low, and the stigma surrounding the disease often prevents open conversations. Public washroom accessibility and reduced stigma emerged as a critical need for IBD patients.
Approach
To reduce stigma, we had to find a way to visualize the realities of washroom access needs for those who live with IBD. To achieve this, we produced a powerful visual centerpiece – an ‘out-of-order’ portable toilet – representing the challenges faced by individuals with Crohn’s or colitis in accessing public washrooms quickly. Through earned and social media, this activation sparked conversation and action on the GoHere® app during Crohn’s and Colitis Awareness Month.
The campaign featured a high-impact public activation and a multi-channel communication strategy:
Call-to-Action: Event materials, earned and social media materials, and conversations encouraged attendees to scan the QR code and download the GoHere® app.
Event Execution: On November 26, 2024, we installed an ‘out-of-order’ portable toilet near Toronto’s Union Station to highlight the urgent need for accessible washrooms. Crohn’s and Colitis Canada staff and volunteers engaged the public with creative materials and a QR code for easy GoHere® app downloads.
Media Engagement: To broaden education beyond the event, we needed national media coverage for our story. This involved securing a nationally syndicated feature story, booking interviews for patient advocates and Crohn’s and Colitis Canada spokespeople, and sharing event photos with media outlets to provide audiences with the powerful visual to include in their stories.
Social Media Strategy: Organic and paid social media posts leveraged hashtags and influencer partnerships, and visual content from the event captured attention and drove app downloads.
Policymaker engagement: To amplify event support and impact, we engaged local MPs and MPPs to demonstrate their support. Mary-Margaret McMahon, MPP for Beaches-East York and Toronto City Councillor, Paul Ainslie, Scarborough-Guildwood, attended the event, shared on their social channels and encouraged GoHere® app downloads. This demonstration of local political support allowed for increased awareness and actionable items for local communities to consider.
Call-to-Action: Event materials, earned and social media materials, and conversations encouraged attendees to scan the QR code and download the GoHere® app.
Results
Over 28.3 million total audience reach through earned and social media tactics
131 stories published by news outlets
Over 9,000 social media engagements (comments, likes and shares)
Seven campaign spokespeople and patient advocates interviewed
One national feature
Seven interviews facilitated
100% of stories included GoHere® mentions
351% increase of daily GoHere® app downloads from November to December 2024, compared to app creation, November 2015 to October 2024
2,221 GoHere® app downloads from November 26-27, 2024
55,136 total GoHere® app downloads from launch of app until December 31, 2024
62x increase in daily average number of GoHere® downloads on November 26 and November 27, 2024, compared to January-October, 2024.
17x increase in average app usage on November 26 and 27, 2024
15x increase in webpage visits to CCC GoHere® site on November 26 and 27
One MPP and one Toronto City Councillor attended the event and amplified our content by sharing it on their personal social media channels
Targownik LE, Bollegala N, Huang VW, et al. The 2023 Impact of Inflammatory Bowel Disease in Canada: The influence of sex and gender on Canadians living with inflammatory bowel disease. Journal of the Canadian Association of Gastroenterology 2023;6(Suppl 2):S55–S63. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcag/gwad011.
VIVIDATA SCC (2024). Study of the Canadian Consumer Digital Fall. Retrieved from https://vividata.ca/
Health
The world of healthcare is constantly changing.
Novel molecules, innovative mechanisms of action, new indications, loss of exclusivity, drug shortages, reimbursement challenges, evolving models of care… and the list goes on.
At ChangeMakers Health, we help clients navigate today’s complexities and anticipate tomorrow’s challenges — all in service of improving care and creating better lives for patients.
We partner with pharmaceutical companies, healthcare organizations and patient advocacy groups. Together, we help patients access potentially life-saving and life-changing medications and treatments. We educate patients and the public about chronic conditions and treatment options. We work to strengthen our healthcare system — ensuring people receive accurate, empowering information to support informed care with our dedicated healthcare providers.
Reputation management in healthcare is built on strong relationships. Relationships which can only be developed through years of hard work and responsibility. We have decades worth of experience to draw upon and have established strong ties with the who’s who of health media.
Key PR & reputation management services
Advocacy and stakeholder engagement
Crisis and issues management
Data intelligence, monitoring and newsjacking
Executive positioning and thought leadership
Influencer/content creator partnerships
Media relations
Health
Marketing & advertising
Pharmaceutical marketing in Canada is complex. We know how to navigate strict regulations and how to work within the guidelines to create breakthrough work — and we’ve got PAAB and Ad Standards wins to prove it.
Key marketing & advertising services
Ad boards
Brand Strategy
Creative concepting, design and production
Digital marketing: websites, SEO/SEM, display, AR/VR, social media, CRM
DTC and HCP marketing campaign development
Medical writing
Collaborations
Endorsements
There are a small number of projects in my career that I remember as the most memorable (for the right reasons). And Locked Out is one I have added to my collection. And the Changemakers team was a partner for that journey. Glad to know it’s also a source of pride for you too!
Paul Kilbertus
Crohn’s and Colitis Canada Senior Manager, Communications and Public Relations
Leadership team
Meaningful change is not possible without collaboration because trust is foundational to great work. Our goal is to become an extension of your team, building a strong and lasting relationship
ChangeMakers secures a major win in eye health advocacy with the Alberta Association of Optometrists
ChangeMakers is proud to announce a major win in health advocacy, securing a strategic partnership with the Alberta Association of Optometrists (AAO) to champion the importance of eye health for all ages.
Through a province-wide campaign, ChangeMakers will help spotlight the critical role of regular eye exams in early detection and prevention, from infancy through to senior years. This collaboration will not only strengthen awareness of eye health but will also mark the beginning of an exciting new client relationship.
“Our partnership with ChangeMakers reflects the agency’s understanding of our mission and its ability to bring it to life through compelling storytelling and strategic communications,” said Brian Wik, CEO at Alberta Association of Optometrists. “We look forward to working together to amplify our advocacy efforts and improve access to essential eye care services.”
As a leader in purpose-driven communications, ChangeMakers will support AAO with a multi-faceted strategy, including strategy, creative and content development, earned media, influencer strategy, digital marketing, and media buying.
“Our work with AAO reinforces ChangeMakers’ commitment to advancing meaningful causes through impactful marketing and reputation management,” said Alyssa Huggins, President of Marketing, at ChangeMakers. “We’re honored to support the Alberta Association of Optometrists in raising awareness of its vital initiatives that protect vision and improve lives across Canada and beyond.”
About ChangeMakers
ChangeMakers is a 400+ person independent reputation management, social impact and marketing firm with offices throughout North America. ChangeMakers combines deep business specialization with human-centered strategies, working alongside our clients to strengthen their reputation and succeed in a disruptive world.
About the Alberta Association of Optometrists
The Alberta Association of Optometrists is Alberta’s leading optometric professional organization, representing more than 900 Doctors of Optometry in over 120 communities across the province. AAO members are highly trained regulated health professionals providing primary eye health and vision care to Albertans. For more information, please visit optometrists.ab.ca.
Expertise and data-driven insights help Canadians understand economics, and help Desjardins build brand trust in the market.
Desjardins Group
The Desjardins Group is North America’s largest financial service cooperative, with more than $470 billion in total assets, serving personal and business services, wealth management, life and health insurance, and property and casualty insurance. Desjardins returned $557 million to members and the community in 2024.
Expertise
Reputation Management
Challenge
While Desjardins Group is a household name in Quebec, it is not as well-known in the rest of Canada. To elevate its profile as a financial services thought leader outside of Quebec, Desjardins expanded its team of economists to provide regular, consistent reporting and insights on macroeconomic trends. Our challenge was to ensure this expertise would resonate with Canadians, connect with their everyday needs and concerns, and strengthen the Desjardins brand.
Insight
Macroeconomics and microeconomics are inextricably linked; Canadians looking to better understand and manage their personal finances benefit greatly from understanding the bigger picture. Amid a shrinking media landscape, there is a thirst for thoughtful, data-driven economic content. Providing relevant, real-world insights and local data, delivered by trusted financial experts can help Canadians feel more informed, more confident and more hopeful.
Approach
Our strategy was three-fold: to leverage Desjardins’ unique dataset – provided by its newly-instated team of economists focused on Ontario, Atlantic and Western Canada (OAW) – to tell stories about Canada’s economy from coast to coast (with a particular focus on provincial-level data); to demonstrate the impact of macroeconomics in Canadians’ everyday lives; and to engage proactively with journalists for relationship-building and enhanced coverage.
Through our collaboration, we expanded our audience by blending traditional media (e.g., BNN) with new media (e.g., The Peak), leveraging relationships held by both our team and the economists. We also hosted in-person events and worked together to amplify reports on key themes like youth, housing affordability, and climate.
Results
By deliberately driving earned media coverage for Desjardins’ newly created economist team dedicated to OAW, we saw an initial 1933% year-over-year increase in ChangeMakers-secured economist media coverage. Additionally, we contributed to doubling the economists’ share-of-voice in markets outside of Quebec compared to the benchmark for Desjardins’ other business divisions (6% vs. 3%).
Since 2022, our focus has been on building new relationships for the economists to leverage directly, which has resulted in new sign-ups for their newsletter, regular commentary in top-tier media outlets across Canada and joint team efficiencies.
Our work has been critical to building the Desjardins brand as a trusted financial services provider in the rest of Canada.
Reaching Vulnerable Youth
Lessons learned from our “Gang Life Is No Life” campaign
Reaching youth in Canada with relevance and impact can be challenging. That task becomes even tougher when the target in question is marginalized Indigenous youth.
It was this objective, engaging marginalized at-risk youth, that was put before ChangeMakers when theManitoba Association of Chiefs of Police asked us to develop a marketing campaign that would encourage at-risk youth in Manitoba to avoid gang membership or leave a gang entirely.
Audience research is often a critical starting point for informing campaign nuances. In this case, it became the bedrock of our marketing plan. ChangeMakers sought to immerse ourselves within this target demographic’s experiences to fully understand what, where, and how to convey our sensitive message.
That meant surveying a broad spectrum of individuals and groups. We spoke to gang prevention officers with the Winnipeg Police Service as well as staff members at The Link, a Winnipeg-based agency that works with marginalized youth and families daily.
Most importantly, we held intense interview sessions with reformed gang members. These streetwise interview participants gave honest and unfiltered answers as to how we might effectively connect with marginalized youth, as well as insights on what we might seek to avoid.
Through this stakeholder research, ChangeMakers’ Social Impact Consulting team arrived at the important understanding that striking the right tone would become a crucial element in our campaign communications. The difficulty in not coming across to youth as “lame” or “corny” can be a hurdle with youth marketing at the best of times. This nuance is magnified further when communicating an issue as fraught and intense as gang membership.
ChangeMakers’ media team examined content and media platforms that were popular among our target demographic and our creative team built the campaign messaging tailored to those digital venues. Additionally, we knew that our ads had to capture our audience’s attention within the first three seconds or else they would be missed.
Based on the insights gathered, we created three short videos that illustrated the vast difference between the myth and the reality of gang life. We employed a video game look and feel that was both relatable and shareable. A text number at the end of each video encouraged viewers to send a message to The Link which was monitored 24/7, offering a lifeline to those seeking help with either leaving gangs or resisting their solicitations.
Our choice of media platforms (TikTok and Snapchat) was perhaps the most important decision in our campaign planning. The campaign’s full-screen mobile video placements, which ran across these platforms, were central to engaging our niche audiences in an immediate and relatable way.
While tone and media were crucial elements in informing our content, subtle information about gang culture was also vital in helping us establish credibility. These insights included scenarios and recruitment tactics that gangs use, as well as the differences between male and female recruitment tactics.
In building the story, we knew our messaging needed to connect and build trust with marginalized youth. By further developing our understanding of their sentiment towards colonial institutions, including policing, we avoided branding our campaign messaging with overt police or law enforcement insignia. Instead, we partnered with The Link, which had already established trust and relevance with this audience. And finally, leaning on the important insights gathered, our messaging was careful to stress that we were in no way advocating “snitching” on existing gang organizations.
Results:
This campaign successfully generated a significant increase in responses from vulnerable youth.
Over the past three years, on average, assistance has been provided to between 20 to 30 youth annually. Following our “Gang Life Is No Life” media campaign, that number jumped to more than 150 referrals (a 600% increase) and conversations between The Link and youth in Manitoba continue each month.
Some Key Lessons Learned:
Youth audiences require authentic messaging. It must feel real.
Young people tire of familiar messaging quickly, so youth campaigns should avoid repetition or shorten their in-market periods
Messages need to resonate quickly and early within digital media
Campaigns involving marginalized youth are more effective when they examine and demonstrate accommodation for sentiment and cultural perceptions
Ongoing analytics are critical to demonstrating campaign efficacy and value with stakeholders
Share
About the Authors
Hilary Friesen / VP, Social Impact Consulting
Hilary is an established expert in fostering behavioural change for organizations large and small. Over more than 17 years, she has led social marketing programs in injury prevention and return to work and has overseen multi-faceted social impact communications programs for diverse public sector clients at ChangeMakers.
Varinder Brar / Director, Social Impact Consulting
Varinder is a Director with 15 years of experience in social impact marketing and communications. He lives in Winnipeg and when he’s not working you can find him coaching basketball at Sisler High School.
Save the Children renews its commitment with ChangeMakers as AOR
ChangeMakers has been named the Agency of Record for Save the Children in Canada, building on the numerous successful campaigns the agency has executed on behalf of the charity since 2023.
“Our continued trust in ChangeMakers reflects the agency’s deep understanding of our mission and ability to bring it to life through compelling storytelling and communications,” said Jessica Bryant, Head of Communications, Media and Public Relations at Save the Children. “We look forward to continuing to work with ChangeMakers to amplify the work we are doing around the world and here in Canada to improve the lives of children.”
With ChangeMakers’ proven track record in purpose-driven and non-profit campaigns, the agency will be providing support in influencer programs, media relations, celebrity ambassador programs, DEI communications, issues management, crisis communications, and digital campaigns.
“Our work with Save the Children underscores ChangeMakers’ commitment to advancing meaningful causes through our reputation management services,” said Caroline De Silva, Senior Vice President, Consumer at ChangeMakers. “We’re honoured to continue supporting Save the Children to elevate its profile in Canada and raise awareness of its critical programs that benefit children around the world.”
About ChangeMakers
ChangeMakers is a 400+ person independent reputation management, social impact and marketing firm with offices throughout North America. ChangeMakers combines deep business specialization with human-centered strategies, working alongside our clients to strengthen their reputation and succeed in a disruptive world.
About Save the Children
Save the Children believes every child deserves a future. In Canada and around the world, we give children a healthy start in life, the opportunity to learn and protection from harm. We do whatever it takes for children – every day and in times of crisis – transforming their lives and the future we share.
Built on a history of peaceful trade, defense and diplomacy, Canada and the United States have shared one of the world’s most interdependent economic relationships since the early 20th century.
A storied united front, the two countries boast the world’s longest undefended border and exchange nearly two billion dollars in goods and services daily.
In recent weeks, these longstanding bilateral ties have been tested. Unprecedented trade turbulence from the Oval Office, with the threat of tariffs (and temporary reprieves) on Canada and Mexico, have set off a chain of panic across North America.
While it may feel impossible to plan as an organization amidst evolving timelines, we’ve developed communications and crisis-preparedness strategies, rooted in real-time data, to prepare for what could lie ahead in this climate of economic unrest.
Here’s what you need to know about the reputational industry shifts, consumer reactions, and key strategies to prepare for what could lay ahead.
Cross-Border Reputation: The Power of Perception
As expected, both countries experienced a notable dip reputationally following the announcement of tariffs.
While Reputation Score allows brands, businesses, and executives to track their health and navigate reputation, we used this tool to understand how the threats of tariffs have impacted cross-border reputation from a geotargeted perspective.
Digital conversations, particularly within pro-Trump communities, have fueled anti-Canada sentiment, while anti-tariff discussions have largely focused on Trump himself rather than offering support for Canada. This demonstrates how trade disputes quickly become emotionally charged, influencing how businesses and brands are perceived.
Industry Impact: Key Sectors in Focus
Despite a brief recovery during the 30-day reprieve, several industries have been hit reputationally as a result of the tariffs discourse. In examining the sector-specific impact, actionable strategies can be implemented by businesses within these spaces to mitigate for further risk.
With heightened consumer anxiety, organizations must be proactive in developing communications and operational strategies that shape their narratives and prepare for potential backlash in an unpredictable policy environment.
Consumer, Lifestyle & Tourism
The initial tariff threat, coupled with uncertainty about its duration, has fuelled a surge in “buy local” rhetoric in Canada. Prime Minister Trudeau’s call for domestic vacations spurred a 150% increase in searches related to Canadian vacations. Similarly, Google search data shows a significant spike in “Made in Canada” queries leading up to the tariffs.
While Canadian consumers may express loyalty to domestic brands, North America’s deeply integrated supply chain makes complete economic independence unrealistic. Businesses should expect continued emotional rhetoric but prepare for practical consumer behavior that blends patriotism with necessity.
Actionable Strategies:
Establish a clear brand narrative to navigate consumer sentiment.
Scenario plan for potential tariff-related price shifts.
Monitor online discourse and adapt marketing strategies accordingly.
Agriculture
Canada and the U.S. have long relied on each other for agricultural trade, but tariffs have sparked discussions about reducing dependence on American imports. February saw a 575% increase in social media mentions of buying Canadian agricultural goods, signalling a shift in public sentiment.
Political rhetoric around Canada’s supply-managed sectors is also naturally intensifying. Businesses should explore new trade partnerships if possible, while strengthening domestic production.
Actionable Strategies:
Diversify supply chains when possible, to mitigate reliance on U.S. markets.
Amplify real-world stories about tariff impacts to foster industry advocacy.
Stay attuned to political developments that could shape future trade policies.
Energy
Canada’s oil and gas sector, responsible for over 60% of U.S. energy imports, faces a 10% tariff as of February 27, threatening price stability and supply chain reliability. For Canadian oil producers, this would represent a nearly US$7-billion hit to their profit. Negative sentiment around Canadian energy exports has spiked, with unfavourable opinions outpacing positive ones by a ratio of 5.5:1.
As tariffs exacerbate uncertainty, the sector may see renewed calls for energy diversification, increased domestic investment, and stronger regulatory support for green energy initiatives.
Actionable Strategies:
Explore alternative energy markets and partnerships, when possible.
Identify champions who can advocate for industry stability.
Align with public sentiment by investing in energy efficiency and sustainability.
Tech & AI
Hard tech goods moving across the border would be directly impacted by prospective tariffs, while AI and digital services remain vulnerable to broader geopolitical tensions. The AI arms race is becoming a critical point of cooperation, with both nations keen on outpacing China’s advancements.
Given the sector’s rapid evolution, businesses must approach AI policy with strategic foresight, ensuring alignment between corporate values and technological adoption.
Actionable Strategies:
Develop a robust AI policy that integrates security and compliance.
Stay ahead of government regulations that may impact AI and cloud services.
Monitor geopolitical trends to anticipate shifts in the digital economy.
Automotive & Transportation
No industry is more vulnerable than North America’s auto sector, where just-in-time supply chains depend on frequent cross-border movement of parts. While tariffs threaten efficiency, public discourse remains surprisingly muted—only 10% of trade-related conversations focus on the auto industry, suggesting that consumers are more concerned with direct consumer goods price increases.
Actionable Strategies:
Strengthen advocacy efforts to highlight the sector’s economic impact.
Develop contingency plans for potential supply chain disruptions.
Align internal teams across legal, government relations, and communications.
Preparing for What’s Next
As the trade pendulum continues to swing and timing remains uncertain, here’s how to stay ahead:
Anticipate long-term changes: The tariff debate is fluid, but consumer sentiment and economic behavior will have lasting effects. Expect stakeholders to be driven by the emotion of the situation and communicate accordingly.
Stay agile: The ability to pivot quickly in response to new developments will be crucial for business survival.
Engage in digital advocacy: The online environment is ripe for brands to take a stance and rally support in a strategic, measured way. Create opportunities for your leaders & advocates to champion industry-wide causes.
Amidst this volatile time, organizations must be proactive, adaptable, and ready to engage with the evolving trade landscape. Through strategic communications, supply chain diversification, and targeted advocacy, now is the time to take decisive action.
Share
About the Authors
Kenny Cameron / Senior Account Manager, Data Intelligence
With over five years of experience in public relations and data analytics, Kenny is an expert in reputation risk management and data-driven communications. Leading ChangeMaker’s Data Intelligence team in Canada, Kenny takes a client-focused approach to social listening and analysis that culminates in actionable takeaways to tackle complex communication challenges.
With a passion for relationship-building and storytelling, Rachel is a trusted communicator, supporting clients through effective reputation management, crisis preparedness and brand strategy. Joining ChangeMakers with roots in the social-change space, Rachel thoughtfully advises and trains partners from a cross-border perspective on the evolving communications, as well as media landscapes in both countries.
ChangeMakers Reputation Index Reveals the Impact of Change Events on Corporate Reputation
Washington, DC, January 28, 2025 —The inaugural ChangeMakers Reputation Index highlights the powerful connection between change events and corporate reputation, uncovering the significant positive and negative impacts of how change is managed. The annual analysis examines 25 companies experiencing five types of change events, both planned and unplanned, and finds that immediacy – both of communication and strategy when a pivot is required – plays a critical role in shaping long-term reputational outcomes. Companies that handle change effectively often bolster their reputation, while those that falter under pressure risk substantial harm.
“In today’s environment, the highest value driver for any organization or individual is reputation,” says Mario Simon, CEO of ChangeMakers. “Preparing for, responding to, recovering from, and even harnessing significant change events is a top priority for any company. This exciting research clearly demonstrates how reputational impacts can and should be managed. Poorly communicated or delayed responses to change events can leave significant value on the table and, in extreme cases, be financially devastating. We have cracked the quantifiable code to manage that for our clients and achieve the best outcomes.”
Importantly, the study revealed that planned business changes—such as seemingly innocuous events such as brand changes and leadership transitions—can have reputational risks as significant as those stemming from unexpected crises.
Key Findings:
Merger & Acquisition Transactions: While mergers and acquisitions often deliver a short-term boost to a company’s reputation, this positive impact tends to fade quickly among stakeholders not directly involved or affected.
Brand Change: Contrary to expectations, brand changes frequently lead to both immediate and long-term damage to reputation. This is often a result of missteps in communication strategy, undermining the intended positive outcomes.
Financial Change: Financial changes produce mixed reputational effects, with positive or negative impacts typically short-lived. However, significant mismanagement can exacerbate negative perceptions. Notably, the absence of proactive, targeted communication with key audiences often results in muted or underwhelming reputational outcomes, even when changes are objectively positive.
Leadership Transition: The reputational effects of leadership transitions hinge significantly on whether the departure is planned or unplanned. How the transition is communicated and managed plays a critical role in shaping public perception.
Public Crisis: The reputational impact of a public crisis is highly contingent on preparation and the company’s ability to respond swiftly and effectively. Organizations that demonstrate readiness and transparency are better positioned to mitigate both immediate and long-term damage.
ChangeMakers is a 400+ person independent reputation management, social impact and marketing firm with offices throughout North America. ChangeMakers combines deep business specialization with human-centered strategies, working alongside our clients to strengthen their reputation and succeed in a disruptive world.
For 2024, we assess the reputation impact on 25 major brands across five high-profile change trigger events, both planned and unexpected.
M&A Transaction (Planned)
Brand Change (Planned)
Financial Change (Planned/Unexpected)
Leadership Transition (Planned/Unexpected)
Public Crisis (Unexpected)
Using the technology of our proprietary Reputation Score we analyze how organizations navigate these moments of change – before, during, and after events unfold.
Highlights of the index include:
A major global fashion retailer’s impressive recovery after a public crisis event.
Why two similar brand changes produce strikingly different outcomes.
Surprising misalignment between financial shifts and brand reputations.
The critical role of proactive communication during leadership transitions.
Lingering power of legacy in M&A transactions.
Dive into ChangeMakers’ Reputation Index 2024 to uncover how major events impact brand reputation and learn what it takes to protect your biggest corporate asset. Your reputation.
In this age of disruption, change is the only constant. It is critical in this complex, competitive environment, for brands, businesses, and executives to know exactly where they stand.
Land acknowledgement, truth and reconciliation action plan
ChangeMakers offices and team members are located across North America within the traditional, Treaty, and unceded territories of First Nations, Inuit, and Métis Peoples.
Our team is currently engaged in the development of a Truth and Reconciliation Action Plan for our company. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada called upon the corporate sector in Canada to “adopt the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples as a reconciliation framework and to apply its principles, norms, and standards to corporate policy and core operational activities involving Indigenous peoples and their lands and resources” (Call to Action 92).
Our Action Plan is an important measure we are taking as a company and we look forward to updating with more information about this plan and the actions that reflect our commitments as a team.
